Experiment
Experiment >> Tactile Strips
City As a Cite: Yellow Tactile Strips
Brief:
Identify an area or aspect of infrastructure or public space in the city to research. Produce a design for the site which builds on an existing landmark or infrastructure, modifying it, or allowing it to have a double function.
Challenge:
What can we add to the yellow tactile strips to improve the effectiveness while still maintaining accessibility & safety of itself?
Research:
​Tactile Strips are regulated by the ADA (American with Disabilities Act with specific dimensions
-
Tactile Surface- Offers both physical and audible cues for cane users when canes come in contact
-
Bright Colors- Eye catching visual cues that alert to danger and caution
-
Pattern- Dots(truncated domes) signal danger, bars provide directional cues
​
Different Platforms:
-
Wide space
-
People walk in the middle with yellow tactile strips on both sides
-
​Often used in densely populated areas (ex. 59th street, 36th street, Atlantic Av-Barclays Ctr, etc)
-
-
​Narrow space
-
Little space to walk with only one side has tactile strips
-
​Often see in small stations (ex. 53rd street, 9th street, Jay Street, etc)
-
​​
Pain Points:
-
People were ignoring the yellow strips and walking it because the subway station was too crowded especially during rush hour
-
Walking on the yellow strips is very dangerous because there is no barrier between the subway track and the platform
-
Some of the platforms had barely enough space for 2 people to walk pass each other
Ideation- LED Lights:
-
LED lights embedded into or between the truncated domes
-
Arduino to program lights to pass along the track in a timed manner
-
Various light patterns that flow in direction of the train arrival
-
Requires physical alteration of tactile strips
-
Maintains bright color attraction
-
Metallic color reflects light
-
Keeps structural Integrity of Tactile Strips
-
Requires adjustment to the entire strip
Ideation- Changing Paint Color:
Finished Prototype:
-
Painted On Text Decal - Maintains physical integrity
-
Bright Contrasting Color - Maintains bright color attraction while still making text visible
-
Thought Invoking Questions -Make passengers pause and ponder on deeper questions
Testing:
-
Out of 15 people, 11 people noticed it
-
A lot more people noticed than ignored the strip
Final Thoughts:
​​Effectiveness
-
Increased Visual Attraction
-
Would catch passerby’s attention
-
-
Slight Increase in pedestrians avoidance of strips
-
Some people ignored the strips altogether and some still stepped on the strip
-
​
Accessibility & Safety
-
Physical Integrity Maintained
-
Painted decal does minimal impact on the physical product
-
Tactile (truncated domes) unaffected
-
-
Bright Contrasting Color
-
Kept the strips visibly bright and eye catching
-
Ideation- Contrasting Color Patterns:
-
Contrasting Colors attract more attention
-
Keeps structural Integrity of Tactile Strips
-
Requires painting on the tactile strips
Ideation- Forced Perspective Text:
-
Eye-catching design
-
Force passengers to stand a certain distance away from tactile strips
-
Customizable text
-
Requires painting on the tactile strips
-
Require large distance for visibility